Good Law Check
Definition
A good law check is the process of verifying whether a cited legal authority remains valid and has not been overruled, reversed, superseded by statute, or otherwise undermined by subsequent legal developments. AI-powered good law checks automate the citator function traditionally performed by Shepard's Citations (Lexis) or KeyCite (Westlaw).
Legal authority is not permanent. Cases are overruled, distinguished, or limited by later opinions. Statutes are amended, repealed, or held unconstitutional. Regulations are revised or vacated. A case that was good law when it was decided may no longer be valid authority today. Citing invalid authority is not just embarrassing; it can result in court sanctions and malpractice liability.
Traditionally, lawyers check the status of cited authority using citator services like Shepard's Citations on Lexis or KeyCite on Westlaw. These services track every subsequent reference to a case and flag negative treatment. AI-powered good law checks automate this process, verifying the status of each cited authority as part of the research or drafting workflow rather than requiring a separate manual step.
AI good law checks go beyond simply flagging negative treatment signals. They can analyze the nature of the negative treatment to determine whether it affects the specific proposition for which the case is being cited. A case that was reversed on procedural grounds may still be good law on the substantive issue. A case that was distinguished on its facts may still be valid for the legal principle it established. This nuanced analysis helps lawyers make informed decisions about which authorities to rely on.
How Irys approaches this
Irys includes automated good law verification that checks the current status of every cited authority and analyzes whether negative treatment affects the specific proposition being cited.
Related terms
Citation Verification
Citation verification is the process of independently confirming that legal citations in a document are accurate: that the cited authorities exist, that quoted language matches the source, that holdings are correctly represented, and that the authorities remain good law. In AI-assisted legal work, automated citation verification is essential to catch hallucinated or inaccurate references before they reach a court or client.
Legal TechAI Cite Check
AI cite check is an automated system that verifies the accuracy and validity of legal citations in a document. It confirms that cited cases exist, checks that quoted language matches the source, verifies that holdings are accurately represented, and flags authorities that have been overruled, reversed, or otherwise undermined.
ResearchAI Legal Citations
AI legal citations are case references, statutory citations, and other legal authority references generated by AI systems in the course of legal research or drafting. The accuracy and verifiability of AI-generated citations is a central concern in legal AI because language models can produce citations that appear well-formed but reference non-existent authorities.
ResearchCourtListener
CourtListener is a free, open-source legal research platform operated by Free Law Project that provides access to millions of court opinions, oral arguments, and judicial records from federal and state courts. It serves as an important public legal data source that some AI legal research tools use as part of their retrieval infrastructure.
See Good Law Check in action
Irys One brings research, drafting, and document intelligence together in one platform. Try it free for 14 days.
Try Irys free